HORNBY EDP2 Ho Lms Ftduchess Athollft Train Set Box Set/box
( Brand: Hornby ), ( Manufacturer Part Number: EDP2 ), ( Part Type: Ho Train Box ), ( Age Level: 17 Years Up )
Review HORNBY Ho Lms Ftduchess Of Athollft Train Set/box
The **Hornby EDP2 HO Scale LMS "Flying Duchess" Atholl Castle Set** is a meticulously crafted, high-quality model railway set that captures the elegance and power of one of Britain s most iconic steam locomotives. This exquisite collection features the legendary **LMS Class 6P "Flying Duchess" No. 6202 "Atholl Castle"**, a masterpiece of pre-war British engineering, renowned for its streamlined design, striking black and yellow livery, and the distinctive "Flying Scotsman" influence that made it a standout among its contemporaries. The locomotive is built to the highest standards of accuracy, with finely detailed components that bring the grandeur of the 1930s to life, including precise cab interiors, authentic valve gear, and a realistic smoke and steam effect that enhances its dynamic operation. Paired with this iconic engine is a **matching tender**, also rendered with exceptional attention to detail, complete with a full water and coal load, ensuring the set is ready for immersive, historically inspired operation.
Complementing the locomotive is a **four-car Mk1 passenger coach set**, painted in the classic **LMS "Coronation" green with cream and red accents**, reflecting the era s luxurious travel experience. Each coach is meticulously detailed, featuring correct window patterns, authentic door handles, and interior lighting that adds depth to the scene. The set also includes a **freight wagon**, allowing for versatile layouts and the option to transport goods alongside passengers, enhancing the realism of the scene. The entire collection is housed in a **durable, high-quality cardboard box** with a striking, full-colour illustration of the locomotive in motion, accompanied by a detailed instruction booklet that guides assembly and operation. This box not only protects the set during transit but also serves as a display piece, showcasing the beauty of the model railway within.
Perfect for both enthusiasts and collectors, this **EDP2 (Easy Drive Plus 2) set** incorporates Hornby s advanced **Easy Drive Plus** technology, offering smooth, responsive control with precise speed and direction adjustments. The **HO scale (1:87)** ensures that the model fits seamlessly into larger layouts or stands proudly as a centrepiece on its own. Whether displayed on a dedicated railway table or integrated into a larger diorama, the **LMS "Flying Duchess" Atholl Castle** set exudes timeless charm and engineering brilliance, making it a must-have for anyone seeking to bring a piece of British railway history to their model railway world. The combination of historical accuracy, craftsmanship, and operational realism ensures that this set is not just a decorative piece, but a dynamic and engaging centrepiece for any railway enthusiast.
The **Hornby EDP2 HO scale LMS Duchess (Atholl) FT train set/box** is a popular model railway set that captures the iconic British steam locomotive of the 1930s. Below is a detailed analysis of its pros and cons, followed by a conclusion and recommendation.
---
### **Pros**
1. **Historical Accuracy and Detail**
The Duchess class locomotives were among the most advanced and powerful steam engines of their time, and this model faithfully replicates their design. The attention to detail including the correct livery (LMS black with red and gold accents for the Atholl variant), intricate piping, and accurate wheel arrangement makes it a highly realistic representation. The FT (Flying Scotsman) version adds further authenticity for enthusiasts of this famous locomotive.
2. **High-Quality Construction**
Hornby is known for its durable and well-engineered models. This set includes a robust chassis, precise articulation (for the tender), and a smooth-running motor. The bodywork is molded with fine details, such as the smokebox doors, cylinder heads, and buffer beams, which enhance its appeal to collectors and operators alike.
3. **Functionality and Features**
The locomotive is equipped with a **DCC-compatible sound decoder** (if purchased separately or as an upgrade), which can add realistic steam effects, bell sounds, and even a chuffing mechanism. The tender is also well-proportioned and includes a realistic fuel/water load. Some versions may include a **coupling system** (e.g., Knuckle or PowerLink) for easy coupling to other Hornby vehicles.
4. **Versatility for Layouts**
The Duchess is a large and imposing locomotive, making it a statement piece on any HO-scale layout. Its size and presence can anchor a scene, whether in a mainline or branch-line setting. The FT variant, in particular, is instantly recognizable and adds a touch of prestige. The tender is also proportionally correct, ensuring the model looks balanced when coupled.
5. **Collectible Value**
The Duchess class is highly regarded among model railway enthusiasts, and this specific set (especially the FT version) holds or appreciates in value over time. It is a sought-after model for both beginners and experienced hobbyists, making it a wise investment for collectors.
6. **Ease of Assembly (for Box Sets)**
If you purchase the set in a **complete boxed format** (e.g., with pre-assembled parts or a ready-to-run locomotive), assembly is minimal. Even if some assembly is required (e.g., attaching the tender or setting up the decoder), the instructions are generally clear, and the parts are well-packaged.
7. **Compatibility with Hornby s Ecosystem**
The model is compatible with Hornby s extensive range of HO-scale track, buildings, and other rolling stock. This makes it easy to integrate into an existing layout or expand a collection. The FT variant, in particular, pairs well with other British steam or early diesel locomotives from the same era.
8. **Educational Value**
For those interested in railway history, this model provides a tangible connection to the golden age of British steam. It can serve as an educational tool for learning about locomotive design, the LMS railway era, or the specific role of the Duchess class in British rail history.
---
### **Cons**
1. **High Cost**
The Duchess (especially the FT variant) is one of Hornby s more expensive models, often priced between ** 150 250 **, depending on whether it includes a decoder or is part of a special edition. This makes it a significant investment, which may deter budget-conscious hobbyists or those just starting out.
2. **Space Requirements**
The model is large and requires ample space on a layout. Its length (locomotive tender) can be challenging to fit on smaller or tightly curved layouts. Operators with limited real estate may find it difficult to position without compromising the overall aesthetic.
3. **Weight and Stability**
Due to its size, the model can be heavy, which may require additional support on the layout to prevent tipping or misalignment. The tender s articulation point can also be a weak spot if not handled carefully during operation.
4. **Decoder and Sound Upgrades (If Not Included)**
While the base model is functional, adding a **sound decoder** (e.g., from Digitrax, MRC, or Bachmann) and realistic steam effects significantly enhances the experience but adds to the cost. Some buyers may find the default sound (if any) underwhelming compared to other modern models.
5. **Maintenance Sensitivity**
Like all high-detail models, the Duchess requires careful handling to avoid damage to delicate parts, such as the smokebox doors or the tender s articulation. Over time, wear and tear (e.g., from coupling or track misalignment) may require occasional adjustments or repairs.
6. **Limited Availability of Accessories**
While the locomotive itself is well-supported, finding matching coaches or wagons for the LMS era can be challenging. Some buyers may need to mix brands or eras to complete a cohesive set, which can disrupt the historical accuracy they initially sought.
7. **Potential for Overcrowding**
On a busy layout, the Duchess s imposing presence can dominate the scene, making it difficult to balance with smaller or more numerous models. Operators with a preference for dense, varied traffic may find it less versatile than smaller locomotives.
8. **Decoupling Issues (If Applicable)**
Some early versions of the model may have had issues with the tender decoupling mechanism, though Hornby has likely addressed this in newer releases. Buyers should check reviews or Hornby s support forums for any known issues before purchasing.
---
### **Conclusion**
The **Hornby EDP2 LMS Duchess (Atholl/FT) train set** is a **highly desirable model** that excels in historical accuracy, construction quality, and visual impact. It is particularly suited for enthusiasts who prioritize realism, collectibility, and the prestige of owning a iconic British steam locomotive. The FT variant, in particular, offers a unique and instantly recognizable addition to any layout.
However, its **high cost, space requirements, and weight** make it less ideal for beginners, those with limited budgets, or operators with compact layouts. Additionally, while the model is robust, it does require careful handling and may benefit from optional upgrades (like a sound decoder) to fully realize its potential.
For **serious collectors, experienced modelers, or those with a dedicated space**, this set is an excellent investment that will enhance both the aesthetic and historical value of a layout. For **casual hobbyists or those on a budget**, it may be more prudent to start with a smaller or less expensive model before committing to such a significant purchase.
---
### **Recommendation**
- **Buy if:** You are an experienced modeler with space for a large locomotive, appreciate historical accuracy, and want a collectible piece that will stand out on your layout. The FT version is particularly recommended for fans of the Flying Scotsman or those seeking a unique centerpiece.
- **Consider alternatives if:** You are a beginner, have a limited budget, or operate on a small layout. In that case, explore smaller or less expensive Hornby models (e.g., the LMS Princess Coronation class or a GWR King class) or wait for sales or special editions that may offer better value.
- **Upgrade options:** If you purchase the base model, consider adding a **sound decoder** (e.g., the MRC or Bachmann DCC sound system) and realistic steam effects to fully enhance the experience.
Ultimately, the Duchess is a **premium model** that rewards those who invest in it with years of enjoyment and admiration. For the right enthusiast, it is a **worthy addition to any HO-scale railway**.
Details:
We'll do our absolute best to make you happy. This set includes 1 powered steam locomotive, tender, 2 passenger cars, transformer, 10 track sections 8 curved, straight. Minor parts replaced. This transformer shows rust on the body and base-plate.
These sections show spots of rust on the rails. Various sections show scratches and nicks on the roadbeds. The instruction manual is included. Train Product Id: 12828310.
Standards for all toy train related accessory items apply to the visual appearance of item and do not consider operating functionality equipment. The locomotive and cars show rust throughout various sections of the chassis trucks. Condition: Very Good C-6Minor scratches and paint nicks, minor surface rust, no dents. Original Box: Yes P-3Incomplete.
The original box is included. The lettering on the face of this transformer is partially faded. This transformer shows scratches and paint loss on the face, body, base-plate. The cars feature tin-plate construction, die-cast trucks, metal wheels, and hook couplets.
Operational Status: Functional This item has been repaired and operates as expected. The electrical cord is worn. Brittle, significant deterioration. The track sections feature tin-plate roadbeds and metal rails.
Overall condition is Very Good. Various sections show paint loss on the roadbeds. These track sections show scratches and spots of black flecks on the rails. The locomotive and cars show scratches spots of paint loss throughout various sections the shell chassis.
Most of the track sections are damaged with loose railing and space between ties. The locomotive features DE-cast construction and a motor. Contacting Train provides us a chance to resolve your issue while allowing you keep the item.
part #: edp2 prices
- $1879.99-$2074.39
specifications klineoscalegi:
- brand: Hornby
- mpn: Edp2
- part type: Ho Train Box
- age level: 17 Years Up
payments klineoscalegi:
- other
- credit card: Visa
- wallet: Paypal
shipping klineoscalegi:
- cost: $76.53
- transit: 4-8 Days
- type: Fixed
- class: Economy, Standard
- service: Economy, Standard
offer klineoscalegi:
- availability: In Stock
- quantity: 1
- options: Ship-to-home
- started: April 16, 2026
- sold: 0
returns klineoscalegi:
- method: Money back
- policy: Returns Accepted
- paid by: Seller
- time: 30 Days
general klineoscalegi:
- condition: Used
- model Railroads Trains > Railroads Trains > Starter Sets Packs
seller klineoscalegi:
- rating: 99.8%
- city: Flowery Branch, Georgia
- # reviews: 750379
Hornby EDP2 Is Similar To:
- B0778m1nsg Hornby The Village Pub Model Set (35.1% similar) Safety warning not suitable under 14 years supervision item specifications perfectly scaled model railway buildings. A wide choice for any era of model and location. Hornby skeletal model's are wonderfully varied in their designs and styles. The hand crafted and decorated poly resin structures can ...(June 14th, 2018)
- L.n.e 460 Hornby Vintage English Clockwork Train Locomotive Green (33.6% similar) Good condition for age and use. Slight rust stains. On offer is this wonderful antique locomotive from Hornby of England. L n e r a clockwork train in green and black. Missing small part from front chimney. Wound it up, spring tight but will not run. A 7 long train...(July 26th, 2018)
- Hornby R1233m Coca-cola Christmas Oo Gauge Train Starter Set (47.4% similar) Train product id: 12617091. Make sure to include your contact and order information when you return items. Standards for all toy train related accessory items apply to the visual appearance of item and do not consider operating functionality equipment. With this set you can create a whole new of ...(August 21st, 2023)
- Hornby R1276t Oo Summertime Coca Cola Train Set (49% similar) We'll do our absolute best to make you happy. Has inner liners. Scale/era: Io scale. Standards for all toy train related accessory items apply to the visual appearance of item and do not consider operating functionality equipment. Finish: painted, color: red, gauge: Io, operator: coke, wheel ...(October 15th, 2023)
- Hornby R1234 Harry Potter Hogwarts Express Electric Train Set Oo Gauge Usa Transformer (42.9% similar) The best way to get there is with the Hornby Hogwarts express train set. This is USA version and works with any standard 120V us outlet ready to attend Hogwarts school of witchcraft wizardry this year. Hornby harry potter Hogwarts express electric train set Io gauge USA transformer, Hornby is the UK...(November 24th, 2023)
- Hornby R9314 Oo Playtrains Thunder Express Goods Battery Operated Train Pack (39.4% similar) Operational status: functional this item is brand new from the factory. Standards for all toy train related accessory items apply to the visual appearance of item and do not consider operating functionality equipment. We'll do our absolute best to make you happy. Contacting train provides us a ...(December 6th, 2023)
- Hornby 055286694219 Amtrak Acela Battery Powered Model Train Set For Parts Not Complete (33.6% similar) This set can be used with just the locomotive and coach making track smaller included pieces or you add these tracks parts to your current setup. Great deal for a partial set. This was an return. The piece that connects the locomotive dummy to coach is broken, so you would have find a way make 2 ...(February 16th, 2024)
- Hornby R1038 Oo Gauge Inch Orient Express Set Ex box (45.3% similar) The original box is included along with a red case for set storage. We'll do our absolute best to make you happy. Wheels show light signs of wear from previous use. Condition: excellent C-7ALL original: minute scratches and paint nicks; no rust or missing parts; distortion of parts. Check the photos...(August 7th, 2024)
- Hornby R.2000 Oo Great North Eastern Railway 125 High Speed Train Ex box (39.7% similar) The instruction manual is not included. Missing inner liners. The original box is included. Condition: excellent C-7ALL original: minute scratches and paint nicks; no rust or missing parts; distortion of parts. Each car features plastic construction, trucks, metal wheels and axles, latch couplets. ...(August 14th, 2024)
- Hornby R2115 Great Western Trains 125 High Speed Train Ex box (47% similar) Overall condition is excellent. The original box is included. Condition: excellent C-7ALL original: minute scratches and paint nicks; no rust or missing parts; distortion of parts. The instruction manual is not included. Operational status: functional this item has been tested and operates as ...(August 14th, 2024)
- Hornby R1234m Oo Hogwarts Express Train Set Ln box (57.7% similar) This set includes: rolling stock 5972 Hogwarts castle, with working headlight Hogwarts, MK1 SK, 99716 bask, 99723 track accessories 3RD radius starter oval train controller R7229 wall plug transformer P9000W power connecting R8206 re-frailer. Train product id: 12398683. Operational status: ...(August 30th, 2024)
